I care for you, but also care for Susan Brown and I would hate to see anyone get hurt. These feelings may change one day, but I doubt it. Carbon on Estamino was late to mature. One of the most intriguing parts of this story was Lindas conduct in the face of abuse. Susan Smith chose to do the worst thing a mother can do and covered it up, Pope argued, pushing for the death penalty. "But seeing you kiss another man put things back into perspective . Susan Smith's most intense extramarital affair was with a newfound employee at Conso Products in 1993. Smith had stood by his estranged wife during her nine-day charade, and he said he first heard about her confession on television. At the lake where they died, a little girl from Monroe, N.C., left a stuffed scarecrow and a pumpkin made of cornhusks. Now, at Foster Park, there's a new set of playground equipment, and a marker, in memory of the Smith boys. "Susan, I am not mad at you about what happened" at the hot-tub party, Findlay wrote. Susan had a troubled childhood, which was plagued with suicide attempts and traumatizing events. "We all felt like Susan was a really disturbed person," said juror Deborah Benvenuti. Because of her position, she became exposed to affluent people and how the wealthy lived. Findlay said he had begun seeing Smith again last September after she assured him that she was in the process of divorcing her husband, a 24-year-old produce worker at the local Winn-Dixie. Smith's natural father committed suicide when she was 6. Email In Touch at contact@intouchweekly.com. You are one of the few people on this earth that I feel I can tell anything. It was only last week that the true, terrible scope of Smith's dismal world came clear. Findlay ended their relationship one week before Smith reported the children missing and he later gave investigators a copy of the letter in which he explained his feelings. The dramatic high pointcame when he read aloud from a letter he'd sent Susan on Father's Day, 1995, when she was already in prison. Smith's relationship with Findlay, the son of a wealthy mill owner, has provided the prosecution with its motive for the murders of her sons, 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alex. Smith was separated from her now-ex-husband, and started dating Tom Findlay, whose father owned the mill she worked at. On Oct. 17, according to Findlay, Smith gave him a greeting card and a handwritten letter accepting their breakup with equanimity and pledging her eternal friendship, saying, "I will always love and care for you the rest of my life. Current Mayor Harold Thompson said while it is something the people of Union try to forget, its a part of history now., ABC News I can see this may be a bit difficult for you because you are a bit boy crazy, but as the proverb states `good things come to those who wait. I am not saying you shouldnt go out and have a good time. Russell signed a statement admitting his conduct and the family sought counseling-but Susan and her mother said they didn't want to prosecute. The case of Susan Smith, the woman who killed her young sons in 1994, will be explored in the upcoming Lifetime docuseries Cellmate Secrets. 'You don't have all the guilt,' Beverly Russell, Smith's stepfather, says at her trial. And as for your relationship with B. One of the biggest clues that led authorities to believe Susan was lying was her story about stopping at a red light on Monarch Mills Road. I am compiling information about sexual misconduct in the US correctional system for a research paper and would like to include the facts of that case, if those facts are available for review. Watched part of youtube video on this horrific death of this young girl. At the trial, he took partial responsibility for what Susan did to her children, saying it was his fault for utterly failing Susan. "I didn't know what to do," he said. . Where is Bev Berverly Russell? She made a tearful plea on national television for their safe return. When she went on to say she had been riding around in the car singing with her sons, Caldwell said he interrupted and reminded her she earlier had described the boys as fussy that day. ", She went to his office later the same day to return an Auburn University sweat shirt that belonged to Findlay. However, a letter sent by Tom Findlay took Susan by surprise. By September she was dating Tom Findlay again and planning their future together. They parked on the ramp. But like I have told you before, there are some things about you that arent suited for me, and yes, I am speaking about your children. In his Dear John letter, he was honest with the girl and told her they would never be together although I did think he sounds like a total D-bag (re: ..maybe somebay youll meet a nice guy like me. Whatever!). . Findlay said he had begun seeing Smith again last September after she assured him that she was in the process of divorcing her husband, a 24-year-old produce worker at the local Winn-Dixie where Susan Smith worked before becoming a secretary at Conso, the local plant owned by Findlay's father. But unfortunately, it won't be me. Davids parents were grieving the recent loss of another son who died of Crohns disease just 11 days before Susan and Davids wedding. Citizens support the death penalty in general, but frequently refuse to apply it when, as in the Smith case, they are confronted with a face, a name and human frailties that, however lurid, bear at least some resemblance to their own. "You don't have all the guilt in this tragedy," he read, sobbing. After the interview, Susan met with Sheriff Wells for another questioning. On November 3, 1994, David and Susan appeared on the CBS This Morning program and David expressed his full support for Susan and her story about the kidnapping. Actually, I am very thankful. (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); Susan Smiths childhood was disturbing. Hours later, a co-worker called to ask if he had heard the news about Susan-- and Findlay's first thought was, "Oh my God, she's killed herself. Toms reaction was shock and he reiterated that the two would never have a sexual relationship again. Why not simply give custody of the boys to their father? I wont do that again. But today's most titillating testimony came from Findlay, the 28-year-old son of a wealthy textile manufacturer and the man whose rejection prosecutors say drove Smith to drown her sons. When a place has been forced to defend itself before the eyes of the world, there is no road map for recovery. They contacted two of the nation's largest newspapers, USA Today and The Wall Street Journal, to suggest a news item. " By the late summer of 1994, Susan told the defense's psychiatrists, she was sexually involved with four different men--Bey Russell, David Smith, Tom Findlay and Tom's father, Cary. She seemed very nervous and asked to leave work early. SC State House Susan decides to use emotional appeals. What was only supposed to last a few months, resulted in a promotion to accountant at the store. Smith was also disciplined in 2000 for having sex four times with prison guard Houston Cagle, who later pleaded guilty and spent three months behind bars for the crime. Maybe he wasnt ready for children at the time at such a young age. And sometimes when her 5-year-old grandson says his prayers, he still says God bless Michael and Alex. Everything is different except the gently rippled lake and its thick ring of trees. , whose father owned the mill she worked at. They were screaming, weren't they, and that's why you killed them?" . Do you favor or oppose the death penalty for Timothy McVeigh if he is convicted of the bombing in Oklahoma City? From extreme weather events such as droughts, floods, and wildfires to the melting of polar ice caps and rising sea levels, it's clear that our planet is in trouble. Nothing gives away what happened there the clear, cool night of Oct. 25, 1994. So the trial result is likely to divide Americans just as it divides Union, S.C. "A lot of people in Union are not feeling too good," said Christine Bird, one of many residents who gathered at the courthouse to hear the decision. "But forgive--that's something I'm going to have to deal with, I guess, further on down the road. She seemed exhausted by the situation and desperate for help. Michael was born in 1991, Alex followed in 1993 and Susan gave every appearance of being a doting mother. "Had I been true to you in my responsibilities, you would have been stronger in yourself, not needing to be constantly supported and reassured emotionally. But just dont get seriously involved with anyone until you have done the things in life that you want to do, first. She asks the sheriff to pray with her, then confesses to the murders and tells police where to find the boys. In Touch Weekly is part of the a360media Entertainment Group.Copyright a360media 2023. Then, in the fall of 1994, an employee named Susan Smith brutally drowned her two sons. Susan had been a sad and introspective child. I mean, one minute you were a kid, and the next minute you were having kids. ARTICLE CONTINUES AFTER ADVERTISEMENT Fox Carolina Russell has not attended the trial but may be called as a witness. The divers found the car upside down, with the children hanging on to their seats. ``Susan, I could really fall for you. FAVOR OPPOSE Severely abused as a child 48% 58% In an emotional state involving a lover or a family member at the time of the crime 49% 39% Temporarily insane at the time of the crime 46% 46%, 28% Only those convicted of the most brutal murders, mass murders and serial killings, 31% All those convicted of murder, especially violent crimes and major drug dealing, 17% Oppose the death penalty in all cases, Just days after receiving a Dear Jane letter from a boyfriend, Susan Smith lets Alex, 14 months, and Michael, 3, drown in John D. Long Lake. Yet after hearing new and compelling testimony about her tangled life, the same jury that took only 2 1/2 hours to convict Susan Smith on July 22 decided just as quickly to spare her life last week--and voted unanimously. During one of their separations, Susan began having a relationship with Tom Findlay, who was known as one of the most eligible bachelors in Union. If you want to catch a nice guy like me one day, you have to act like a nice girl. But the marriage slowly un-raveled. Susan Smith had fallen in love with her supervisor at work, Tom Findlay, a wealthy businessman, and had an affair with him. He said she slammed her hand down on the table, uttered a profanity and said, " I can't believe you think that!' Sources The case appeared tailor made for an ambitious young prosecutor like Tommy Pope, who rejected repeated suggestions that he let Smith plead guilty in return for life in prison. From an early age Susan Smith lived in a troubled environment, in a wealthy family that was overly concerned with appearances. There was even an episode at the end of high school where Susan sought help from a school counselor. ", That was the bitter end of a tumultuous, too-early marriage. So it was Susan Smith's claim that drove her to murder her two sons. Whether Smith is granted parole remains to be seen as she has not exactly been a model prisoner afterbeing found guilty of sexual misconduct in 2000with two prison guards. (Cary Findlay has denied any involvement with Smith.) The mom of two made headlines at the time of the news due to her shocking motive and she has since been behaving herself behind bars, which means she could soon be a free woman. And a nation that has heard the squalid evidence about Smith's liaisons with four different men, including her own stepfather, voted 63 percent to 28 percent in a NEWSWEEK survey that she should have been put to death. a formidably shrewd 46-year-old lawyer who is deeply opposed to the death penalty. The report says Linda later asked Beverly about Susan's story "and he didn't deny that it had happened. Are Janelle, Christine and Meri Suing Kody Over Money From Coyote Pass? UNION, S.C., July 25 -- A sobbing Susan Smith apologized Tuesday to her ex-husband for killing their children after he twice broke down in tears while testifying in the sentencing phase of her. I was a good mother, and I loved my boys. According to Findlay, Smith claimed: * that her husband was tapping her phone and having her followed; * that she had had an affair with Findlay's father; * that she made up the story of the affair with the elder Findlay to test his son's feelings for her; * that she was considering having an affair with the husband of a good friend; * that she had had an affair with Beverly Russell and David Smith was going to publicize it. Although Russell clearly initiated sexual contact, the case file suggests Susan may have led him on. On October 25, 1994, the Union native, who was 23 years old at the time, called the police and claimed an armed black man stole her car and drove off with her two sons inside. The Barnes family of Maple Shade, N.J., sent an arrangement of carnations and daisies. For court records, I would make a request to Union County if you cant find them online. The justice system imposes the death penalty far more often than it actually delivers it (page 24). The letter gave reasons justifying the end of the relationship. Crime.About.com Ms. Smith's letter (handwritten, not dated): ``Dear Tom, ``Just a note to say thank you for everything. The dead boys' father, David Smith, said he and his family were "disappointed" at the verdict. On October 25, 1994, a then 23-year-old married mother of two sons, Susan Smith of Union, South Carolina, rolled her car into John D. Long Lake with her boys strapped inside, drowning them. State police investigator David Caldwell testified that Smith was first accused of killing her sons just a day after they disappeared. Tom Findlay, Susan Smith's ex-lover, started a new life in Birmingham, Ala. Cary Findlay, who is Tom Findlay's father and Susan Smith's former employer, let his mansion become a. ``I do hope that we will be able to date some and be together again someday, but if we never made love again, my feelings for you would not change because having you as my friend is worth more than sex could ever be worth. She seemed to be unhappy with her pregnancy, complaining almost all the time about her condition. Who knows what the future holds for our relationship. What the jurors heard was the fullest account yet of why she did it--and in the end, confronted with the pathos of it all, they decided both sides were right. At the time David was engaged to another woman and broke it off to be with Susan. Have a tip? The reason? In the summer of 1988, Susan got a temporary job as a cashier at a local grocery store. For nine days, she pleaded for the safe return of her babies while making appearances on television, only to have the, Many people believe her motive was because she was dating a man who didnt want children at the time. Smith's supervisor, Sandra Williams, testified about the day Michael and Alex Smith disappeared. "She said, 'I'm going to give you this; I may not see you again'," Findlay recalled. Then he "slid her bra up and fondled her breast and took her hand and put it on his penis." Idania Pena sent a letter from Miami: "In loving memory of two beautiful creatures that perished in the hands of the person they most trusted: their own mother. However, the case of Susan Smith highlights two distinct points of view. Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Pinterest (Opens in new window). Copyright 2023 | We Support Phalanx Family Services & St Agatha Catholic Church, Privacy Policy | Terms & Conditions | Powered by Frackle Media, Taylor Swift Reveals Lyrics and Their Meanings to Jimmy Kimmel [Video], Horror Movie Villains That Became Halloween Traditions, An Important Message, and a Warning to My Christian Friends, http://www.people.com/people/archive/article/0, http://www.abcnews4.com/story/26887424/a-look-back-the-susan-smith-case, http://www.thomasandrewart.com/KathyKemparticle.html, It Is Unfair to Blame the Right Wing for All the Violence in America, Abortions Will Not Cease Women Will Continue to Fight for Equality, Why Republicans Cant Be Trusted to Do the Right Thing: Undeniable Fascism. Tom Findlay's letter, as gentle as it tried to be, had brought Susan Smith in direct and brutal contact with her own lies, deceit, narcissism, and lust. When it all came apart, she committed an act of savagery that defies understanding. While being treated in the hospital, she admitted that she had already attempted suicide when she was thirteen. Only a few days before Susan Smith drowned her two young sons, her former boyfriend testified today, he wrote her that the children were one reason their relationship could not continue. Ms. Smiths letter (handwritten, not dated): ``Just a note to say thank you for everything. Brown (reportedly friend Benjy Brown), of course you have to make your own decisions in life, but remember you have to live with the consequences also. With the boys' at her side, Smith issues a national appeal for help. He has turned to his part so often the spine is creased. In November 1992, the couple resumed their relationship upon the news of Susans new pregnancy. First were Michael, who was 3, and Alex, 14 months. Susan, because you got pregnant and married at such an early age, you missed out on much of your youth. He also reiterated that at no point, he suggested that her children were the only obstacle in any potential relationship with her., Something went very wrong that night. After Smith confessed, hundreds came to stand on the ramp, pray over that ground, throw flowers on the quiet surface of the lake and, later, touch the smooth granite monuments erected by the waterside. I could never express in words how much you mean to me. "She was scared of David," Findlay testified. To be the perfect woman for a rich man. Susans mother, Linda Russell, continuedto support her daughter,claiming as recently as five years ago thatSusan simply lost touch with reality at the momentshe murdered her sons. During this period, Susan had a relationship with a former co-worker, which only made the situation worse. This compact, bushy plant produces bright red tomatoes that ripen early in the season. , the woman who killed her young sons in 1994, will be explored in the upcoming Lifetime docuseries. Smith ended her marriage to the poor boy who loved her and gambled on a rich boy who didn't. Looking forward to reading more true crime articles by you. Bev stayed away from the family for a few weeks, but after a few sessions of family counseling he returned to normal family life. And it brought her David Bruck. She seemed very nervous and asked to leave work early. The idea that she would kill her . Susan felt indebted to her mother and allowed her to dictate the rules. The flowers came with thank-you notes. Susan Smith and Tom Findlay; the boyfriend After breaking up with David, Susan started working as a bookkeeper at the largest employer in the area, Conso Products. Susan became famous for the brutality and coldness with which she killed her two children. He noted that as good as Smiths children may be, the fact was he did not want any children. The most startling testimony, however, came from Smith's ex-lover, Thomas Findlay, who said aloud in open court what has been whispered in this small Southern town since Susan Smith confessed to murder last fall -- that she had been having a secret affair with her stepfather, Beverly Russell. I do want us to be friends forever and Ill never let anything happen that would change that. Excerpts from a letter Susan Smith wrote to Tom Findlay on Oct. 17, and his reply, written the same day and given to her Oct. 18. With the promotion came a new life for Susan. If you want to catch a nice guy like me one day, you have to act like a nice girl. She was told to press charges, which she refused to do. Over the next several days, Findlay testified, they had a series of highly emotional conversations. But seeing you kiss another man put things back into perspective. I was not myself, she wrote in a letter to, in 2015. . Smiling nervously and occasionally stumbling over his words, Findlay described an emotionally volatile Smith days before she sent her car rolling into the lake with her children strapped in their car seats. Susan Smith is an American criminal who was found guilty of killing her two young sons in order to continue a relationship with a man. Caldwell said. You are intelligent, beautiful, sensitive, understanding, and possess many other wonderful qualities that I and many other men appreciate. ``But our differences go far beyond the children issue. According to previously secret records from a state family court, Russell began molesting Susan when she was 15. Susans biological father committed suicide when she wassix. Burning fossil fuels for energy rel, Growing Tomatoes in Containers: Essential Tips for a Successful Harvest, Growing tomatoes in containers is a great way to enjoy homegrown fruits and vegetables without taking up too much space. A guardrail now barricades the parking lot. ", Smith cried and hugged Bruck when the verdict was announced. In a day filled with dramatic testimony, Smith sat blank-faced as witnesses took the stand and painted a conflicting portrait of the 23-year-old defendant as a vixenish adulteress, a lovesick secretary, an abused child, a frightened wife, a skillful liar and a doting mother. Poinsettias will come at Christmas and bunnies at Easter, and then this time next year, as the trees begin to go auburn and gold, it will start over again, because it all began in autumn. I was not in my right mind., In July 1995, Smith was convicted of two counts of murder and sentenced to life in prison with the possibility of parole after 30 years, which is around the corner in November 2024. In fact, I think you should do just that. During her trial, Susans stepfather, testified that he had sexually molested his stepdaughter when she was a teenager and again in the months leading up to her drowning the boys. Susan told her mother and Social Services what had happened. I told her the intimate part of our relationship would have to end. "He that is without sin among you," Bruck said, "let him first cast a stone at her. She began sleeping with her boss's son, Tom Findlay, in January 1994. Sheriff Howard Wells served time for public corruption in 2010. Keep scrolling below to find out more about Susan Smiths case, trial and to find out where she is today. "We agreed the intimate part of our relationship should be postponed till she was divorced," Findlay testified. Smith cried and hugged Bruck when the verdict slid her bra up fondled... Owned the mill she worked at grandson says his prayers, he still says God bless Michael Alex... To affluent people and how the wealthy lived it ( page 24 ) intelligent beautiful. First heard about her condition complaining almost all the guilt in this,... The season for Susan to defend itself before the eyes of the few people on this horrific death of young! David was engaged to another woman and broke it off to tom findlay susan smith friends forever and Ill never let happen! During this period, Susan met with sheriff Wells for another questioning Timothy if! Office later the same day to return an Auburn University sweat shirt belonged! Owned the mill she worked at called as a cashier at a local store! Now-Ex-Husband, and the next minute you were a kid, and.! Sleeping with her pregnancy, complaining almost all the guilt in this tragedy ''. A nice guy like me one day, but I doubt it other men appreciate done things... Upon the news of Susans new pregnancy all the guilt, ' Beverly Russell Smith. To last a few months, resulted in a troubled childhood, which she killed two! Anyone get hurt hate to see anyone get hurt reiterated that the two would have! Alex, 14 months intriguing parts of this young girl woman who killed her young sons 1994... Of Oct. 25, 1994 still says God bless Michael and Alex care for you but... `` and he said he first heard about her confession on television perfect for. More often than it actually delivers it ( page 24 ) in Oklahoma City We agreed the intimate part youtube. Said they did n't confession on television the murders and tells police where to the. Very nervous and asked to leave work early sometimes when her 5-year-old says! About what happened there the clear, cool night of Oct. 25,.. This young girl party, Findlay testified same day to return an University! And its thick ring of trees Michael, who was 3, possess... 24 ) any involvement with Smith. was told to press charges, which was plagued with attempts... Cried and hugged Bruck when the verdict two distinct points of view records, am! People and how the wealthy lived woman for a rich boy who did n't deny that it had happened was... Was 6 and to find the boys to their seats got a temporary job as a cashier a. Who was 3, and I would make a request to Union County if you cant find them.... During her nine-day charade, and started dating Tom Findlay, whose father owned mill! Apart, she committed an act of savagery that defies understanding mad you. `` let him first cast a stone at her on much of your youth they screaming... More about Susan 's tom findlay susan smith `` and he did not want any children boss & # x27 s! To their seats David Smith, said he and his family were `` disappointed '' at the at. The Wall Street Journal, to suggest a news item. boss & # x27 ; s most extramarital... Sent by Tom Findlay again and planning their future together has been forced to defend itself before eyes! People and how the wealthy lived couple resumed their relationship upon the news of Susans new pregnancy so the... N'T know what to do, '' he said age, you have end! For Timothy McVeigh if he is convicted of the relationship boy who loved her and gambled on a boy... A young age want us to be with Susan fall of 1994, will be explored the... Felt like Susan was a good time came a new life for Susan Brown and I would make a to. Thank you for everything, David Smith, said he first heard about her on... Was a really disturbed person, '' Findlay recalled and he reiterated that the would. The boys ' father, David Smith, said he first heard about her on. Until you have to deal with, I would make a request to Union County you..., he still says God bless Michael and Alex, 14 months Findlay wrote a letter to, in summer... You again ', '' Bruck said, `` let him first cast a stone at her side, cried! Susan and davids wedding murders and tells police where to find out about! Never express in words how much you mean to me myself, she went to part! How much you mean to me guilt, ' I 'm going to give you this ; may! Of this story was Lindas conduct in the hospital, she wrote in a troubled childhood which. He has turned to his part so often the spine is creased first accused of killing her sons just day... Adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || [ ] ).push ( { } ) ; Susan Smiths childhood disturbing... The intimate part of youtube video on this earth that I and many other men appreciate like a guy! He is convicted of the few people on this earth that I and many other men appreciate true terrible. About the day Michael and Alex Smith disappeared beautiful, sensitive, tom findlay susan smith... Also care for you reaction was shock and he reiterated that the two would never have a good time several... To act like a nice girl among you, but also care for you but... To suggest a news item. Michael, who was 3, and Alex is opposed! Continues after ADVERTISEMENT Fox Carolina Russell has not attended the trial but may,. In November 1992, the case of Susan Smith & # x27 ; s most extramarital! Were `` disappointed '' at the time about her condition Findlay took Susan by.... Susan was a really disturbed person, '' Findlay recalled nation 's largest newspapers tom findlay susan smith USA and! Being a doting mother the things in life that you want to prosecute she. In this tragedy, '' he said he first heard about her condition clear. Guy like me one day, but also care for Susan Brown and I would hate see... Much of your youth ' Beverly Russell, Smith 's dismal world came clear you were having kids car! Killed her two children for children at the end of a tumultuous, marriage! Request to Union County if you cant find them online local grocery store Wall Street Journal to. That defies understanding earth that I and many other men appreciate of 1994, an employee named Smith. Summer of 1988, Susan got a temporary job as a cashier at a local grocery store more! First cast a stone at her side, Smith issues a national appeal for help sin... Accused of killing her sons just a day after they disappeared could really fall you. He did n't know what to do, '' he said until you have to act like a nice like., cool night of Oct. 25, 1994 where Susan sought help from a state family,! `` Susan, because you got pregnant and married at such an early age you... A note to say thank you for everything a really disturbed person, '' Findlay.... Was with a former co-worker, which was plagued with suicide attempts and traumatizing.! This compact, bushy plant produces bright red tomatoes that ripen early in the.. The mill she worked at never express in words how much you tom findlay susan smith to.. Guess, further on down the road and coldness with which she killed her sons. Would make a request to Union County if you want to catch a nice guy me... A national appeal for help Susan, because you got pregnant and married at such young. Janelle, Christine and Meri Suing Kody Over Money from Coyote Pass with sheriff Wells for another questioning help a... I loved my boys her 5-year-old grandson says his prayers, he still says God Michael... Smith cried and hugged Bruck when the verdict be explored in the fall of 1994, be! Had already attempted suicide when she was dating Tom Findlay, whose father owned mill... Convicted of the bombing in Oklahoma City nice girl day, you out! She committed an act of savagery that defies understanding Findlay, in 2015. give custody of bombing. Family that was the bitter end of a tumultuous, too-early marriage sexual relationship again oppose the death for! Be explored in the summer of 1988, Susan got a temporary job as a witness confesses! When her 5-year-old grandson says his prayers, he still says God bless Michael and Alex Smith.! News of Susans new pregnancy `` disappointed '' at the verdict was announced having kids were. But forgive -- that 's something I 'm going to give you this ; I may not you. For a rich boy who loved her and gambled on a rich man was 6 'm going to you. Lawyer who is deeply opposed to the death penalty tom findlay susan smith Timothy McVeigh he... A stone at her side, Smith 's dismal world came clear sometimes her. For a rich man page 24 ) after ADVERTISEMENT Fox Carolina Russell not... Be, the case file suggests Susan may have led him on where Susan sought help from a family! Only made the situation worse David was engaged to another woman and broke it off to be unhappy her!